On Lindsay Lohan’s reaction to him in the audition room, his surprise kiss with Jamie Lee Curtis, and the real reason his hair was so long.

As divided as Gen Z can get, one thing unites us all: the early 2000s had some great celebrity crushes. Thanks to rom-coms and teen dramas, we got cuties like Dylan Sprouse and Taylor Lautner (not to mention all of The Sex and the City boyfriends).

Sorry, fans, but Chad’s been happily married to his wife, Sarah, for more than a decade. Learn all about her and their family here!